Drawing (Pattern) vs PIN vs Face ID: Which Is Safer?

There’s no single winner. Face ID is hard for a stranger to fool, a long PIN is hard to copy by watching, and a drawing is quick but easy to spot. The right choice depends on who you are guarding against.

People argue about unlock methods as if one of them is simply “most secure”. Security researchers look at it differently: each method resists some attacks and gives way to others. A fingerprint can’t be overheard; a PIN can’t be lifted from a photo of your face; a pattern is easy to remember but easy to see.

Here is what each one is good at, with numbers from Apple and from peer-reviewed studies, and how to make whichever you use stronger.

Best second key for private photos: a drawing that isn’t your phone’s unlock

Vaultmira uses a drawing on a 5×5 grid, larger than the familiar 3×3, and you can turn off the line that follows your finger. What makes it useful is not the shape itself but that it’s separate: someone who knows your passcode or can use your face still has nothing that opens the vault.

Get Vaultmira on the App Store

Who Are You Guarding Against?

Threat Face ID 6-digit PIN Drawn pattern
A stranger who finds your phone Strong Strong Fair (depends on the pattern)
Someone who watched you unlock Not affected Best of the three Weakest, especially with lines shown
Smudges on the screen Not affected Some risk Higher risk
A twin, sibling or young child Weaker, per Apple Not affected Not affected
Someone who can make you look at the phone Weak You decide whether to type it You decide whether to draw it
You need to change it after a leak Impossible Easy Easy

Face ID: Strong Against Strangers

Apple says the probability that a random person could unlock your iPhone with Face ID is less than 1 in 1,000,000 with one enrolled appearance, and only five failed matches are allowed before the passcode is required. It is also attention-aware and checks that your eyes are open (About Face ID advanced technology). For Touch ID, Apple’s figure is less than 1 in 50,000 (Apple Platform Security).

Apple is also open about the limits: the odds are higher for twins and siblings who look like you, and for children under 13. Adding an alternate appearance lowers the bar too (up to 1 in 500,000 with two). And Face ID always falls back to your passcode, so it is never stronger than that passcode.

PINs: Hardest to Copy by Watching

In a large study of 1,173 people at ACSAC 2017, participants watched videos of someone unlocking a phone and tried to repeat it. A 6-digit PIN was copied after one look in just 10.8% of attempts, rising to 26.5% with several looks (Aviv et al., Towards Baselines for Shoulder Surfing). Longer PINs and alphanumeric passcodes are harder still. Apple lists Custom Alphanumeric Code and Custom Numeric Code as the most secure iPhone passcode options.

Drawn Patterns: Easy to Remember, Easy to See

64.2%
6-dot patterns copied after one look, lines shown
35.3%
Same, with the lines hidden
10.8%
6-digit PINs copied after one look

The same study found 6-length patterns with visible lines were repeated after one look 64.2% of the time. Hiding the lines cut that to 35.3%. Earlier work found more problems: people choose predictable shapes on the 3×3 Android grid, often starting top-left, so typical patterns were weaker than a random 3-digit PIN for guessing the easiest 20% (Uellenbeck et al., CCS 2013). And oily smudges on a screen can reveal a pattern’s path (Aviv et al., Smudge Attacks, WOOT 2010).

Honest Takeaway

If you only had one lock for your whole phone, a long PIN or passcode would usually beat a pattern. Patterns earn their place when they are a second key, drawn rarely, in private, with the line hidden.

Why Vaultmira Uses a Drawing Anyway

Vaultmira isn’t your phone’s lock. It is the key to a few private vaults, opened now and then. For that job, a drawing has real advantages, and we’ve tried to remove its weak spots:

A 5×5 drawing (example)
  • It’s separate. Vaultmira has no Face ID or passcode way into a vault. Someone who knows your passcode, or can hold the phone up to your face, still can’t open it.
  • A bigger grid. 5×5 dots instead of 3×3, and a drawing needs at least 6 dots and one turn, which rules out the simplest straight lines.
  • Lines can be hidden. Turn off “Show my drawing as I draw”, the setting the research above suggests matters most.
  • No “wrong” message. A shape that isn’t a vault opens an empty one, with no error. Watching someone try a shape tells an onlooker nothing about whether it was right.
  • Slow to guess offline. Each drawing is run through PBKDF2-HMAC-SHA256 600,000 times before it becomes a key, so trying shapes against copied files is slow work. More in Drawing encryption.

The Right Lock for Each Job

Job Good choice Why
Unlocking your iPhone many times a day Face ID plus a long passcode Quick, strong against strangers, passcode as backup
Your Apple Account and payments Passcode, with Stolen Device Protection on Apple then asks for Face ID with no passcode fallback for some actions away from home
A vault of private photos A separate drawing or password It must stay closed to people who know your phone’s unlock
Recovering that vault A written backup phrase A long phrase is hard to guess and easy to store offline

Apple’s Stolen Device Protection is a good example of mixing methods: away from familiar places, some actions need Face ID or Touch ID with no passcode alternative, and changing your Apple Account password adds an hour’s wait. It protects the account even from a thief who saw your passcode.

If Someone Pressures You to Unlock

No unlock method helps if someone can make you use it. Vaultmira’s panic drawing (Pro) is built for that moment: mark a vault you’re comfortable showing, and drawing its shape opens it while erasing the other vaults from that phone. Copies already in your Encrypted iCloud Backup are kept, so drawing a real shape later on a phone that’s online brings a vault back. It is a tool, not a safety plan; read Someone insists you unlock your phone first.

How to Make Any Unlock Stronger

  • Passcode: go to Settings → Face ID & Passcode → Change Passcode → Passcode Options and pick a custom code.
  • Face ID: if someone may have added an alternate appearance, Apple suggests Settings → Face ID & Passcode → Reset Face ID, then set it up again.
  • Drawing: use more than the minimum dots, include turns, avoid letters and your initials, and don’t reuse your phone’s old Android pattern.
  • Everywhere: unlock facing a wall in public, and wipe the screen now and then.
  • Keep a recovery. A Vaultmira backup phrase lets you choose a new drawing if you think yours was seen.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a pattern lock safer than a PIN?

Usually not, for unlocking a whole phone. Research found patterns easier to copy by watching and often predictable. A pattern works better as a separate, rarely used key with the line hidden.

Is Face ID safer than a passcode?

Against strangers it is very strong. But it can’t be changed, it’s weaker for twins, siblings and young children, and it always falls back to your passcode, so the passcode still matters.

Can someone open my vault with my face while I’m asleep?

Not in Vaultmira: vaults open only with your drawing or backup phrase. Apple adds that Face ID is attention-aware and checks your eyes are open.

How many dots should my drawing use?

Vaultmira needs at least 6 dots and one turn. More dots and more turns make a shape harder to guess and to remember from a glance.

What if someone saw me draw my shape?

Open the vault, go to Vault Settings and tap Change drawing for this vault. If you can’t open it, use the backup phrase on the draw screen first.

Related reading:

Keep it private, for real

Hidden is not the same as locked. Vaultmira seals your photos and files on your iPhone behind a shape only you know.

Download Vaultmira Free